Dreaming of long, splash-filled afternoons in your garden? A pool is one of the best ways to stay cool during summer. But when choosing between a steel-frame and an inflatable pool, how do you know which one is right for you?
In this guide, we’ll explore the key differences between inflatable and metal-frame pools, looking at everything from durability and setup time to cost, depth, and long-term care.
Whether you’ve got limited space or a bigger back garden for larger pools, we’ll help you make an informed decision for your family.
Structure and durability: metal frame vs inflatable
A major difference between inflatable and steel-frame pools is their structure.
-
Inflatable pools rely on air pressure to hold their shape. They’re typically shallower pools made from flexible PVC or vinyl and have an inflatable top ring to create structure.
-
Metal-frame pools feature a sturdy frame made from steel or resin and a fitted pool liner that provides support for the pool walls. These frame pools are part of the above-ground pool category and are considered a more durable option.
Durability tip: Inflatable pools offer convenience but are more prone to punctures, while metal frame pools require more effort to install but offer added durability and a longer pool lifespan.
Setup and installation: quick dip or weekend project?
If you're after something quick and easy, inflatable pool installation is generally faster. All you need is a level spot in the garden and an air pump.
-
Inflatable pools are typically smaller and can be set up in minutes.
-
Metal-frame pools require assembly of the frame and liner placement. This process is more labour-intensive but provides a more stable, semi-permanent structure.
Both options often come with basic pool accessories like a filter pump, pool cover, and ladder. For safety, be sure to follow the manufacturer’s instructions.
Size, depth, and space
Inflatable paddling pools are typically smaller and best for young kids or quick cooldowns. Depth ranges from just a few inches to about 3 feet.
Steel frame pools offer larger pools suitable for swimming, play, or hosting larger groups. If you’ve got more swimmers or older children, a frame pool is likely the better fit.
For limited space, inflatable is a convenient option, but if you want something more substantial in your own backyard, a metal-frame pool is the way to go.
Longevity and maintenance
-
Inflatable swimming pools generally last two to five years with proper maintenance.
-
Steel-frame pools, when properly maintained, can last much longer thanks to their solid structure and sturdy frame.
Both types require attention to water chemistry, cleaning, and pool maintenance. A pool liner can extend the life of your pool if checked and cared for regularly.
For improved hygiene, some advanced features like saltwater systems and additional filtration systems are more common in frame pools.
Portability and storage
-
Portability of inflatable pools is a big win. They’re generally easier to move, deflate, and store for the off season.
-
Steel-frame pools take longer to disassemble and require more space to store, but they’re great if you plan to leave your pool up all summer.
Inflatable and metal-frame pools can both be moved or stored, but inflatable pools are better for renters or those who want a budget-friendly option that doesn’t take up too much space when not in use.
Cost comparison
-
Inflatable pools offer the lowest upfront cost. They’re budget-friendly, often including a basic pump, ladder, and cover.
-
Frame pools cost more, but they tend to come with more advanced features and last longer, reducing your overall cost in the long run.
Models like the Bestway Power Steel Swim Vista offer affordability with added strength and proper maintenance means it can last multiple seasons.
Final thoughts: which pool is best?
Choose an inflatable pool if:
-
You have young kids
-
You want quick and easy setup
-
You’re working with limited space or want portability
Choose a steel frame pool if:
-
You want a durable, semi-permanent setup
-
You have space for larger pools
-
You’re looking for better depth, pool walls support, and advanced features
If you want to learn about how you might empty your steel frame pool before buying, learn from our guide - How to Empty a Steel-Frame Pool.
Whatever your choice, keeping the pool water clean, checking the air pressure (for inflatables), and maintaining your pool’s condition will extend its life, and the summer fun!
Shop pools and accessories at Outdoor Toys
Ready to find the perfect fit for your family? From inflatable paddling pools to steel-frame ground pools, Outdoor Toys has everything you need to turn your garden into a summer splash zone.
Shop today for pool accessories, filter pumps, and water slides, keeping your water clean, cool, and safe all season long.